Leave a legacy.

Reforming the Ideas comments section

By: various_mm | 29-05-2016 12:34



my ideas is about how comments in the "comments"  section of the ideas page are displayed.


i think it order to allow better discussions, each comment within the "ideas comments section" should have the option of having the ability to reply direct to that thread. 


at the moment comments are displayed just by date order and are not grouped in anyway.


this way each comment can have a thread underneath it so that it allows people to discuss things more meaningfully.


for example.


person A: this is great idea

            person B: i think we need to look more into it

            person C: yes, i think you are right


person D: how much will this costs







by: iqbal92307
on: 06-08-2019 19:32

Great idea

by: peterg92
on: 16-05-2019 10:38


by: adamtheant
on: 11-03-2019 20:38

dont think this is needed

by: bertiebat
on: 27-08-2019 11:25

Well it's been live for a while now. If you read through the comments you will have seen this.

by: emmalouisep93
on: 12-01-2019 21:56

Good luck

by: bertiebat
on: 27-08-2019 11:25

Next time read the comments before spamming please.

by: derun1983
on: 07-09-2017 00:27


by: prescilla_g giffgaff Staffer
on: 31-07-2017 13:20

Afternoon all,

Just a quick one to let you all know that this idea has been implemented. You can now reply to specific comments and your reply will thread underneath, making it easier to have discussions and generally, keep our comments section a little neater and easier to understand.

Nice one various_mm. Congrats on getting this idea to the top and a big thank you to everyone who supported it.


by: jeff_elephant
on: 27-07-2016 17:33

don't agree. it's fine as it is

by: gindygoo
on: 07-06-2016 19:29


As you've just described what posting in contribute is all about, I'll be down voting your idea.

by: zagzig
on: 30-05-2016 20:41

Great suggestion! It would enable a meaningful exploration of the idea, and it would encourage helpful discussions. At the moment posts in the comments section can seem random if they are in response to another post in the comments thread. I also think 'likes' or 'kudos' would be helpful in the comments section.

The layout and functionality of the labs section is a mess, in my opinion. I'm surprised anyone uses labs, the way it is now. I find it almost impossible to navigate.


by: sarahbanahnah
on: 30-05-2016 15:54

What will be the purpose? Plus this needs lithuim